 |
| Image Source :: Maria Grazia Picciarella/SOPA Images/LightRocket via Getty Images |
This week’s news out of the Catholic Church has shook up conversations from parishes to pulpits. Cardinal Timothy Dolan, long the face of the Archdiocese of New York, has stepped down and been succeeded by Bishop Ronald Hicks of Joliet, Illinois. It’s a shift that’s about more than just names on a letterhead — it signals a change in tone, priorities, and leadership style in one of the most influential dioceses in the United States. Reuters+1
Let’s unpack what happened, why it matters, and what it might mean for the future of the Church in New York and beyond.
A Long Tenure Ends: Who Is Cardinal Timothy Dolan?
For 16 years, Cardinal Timothy Dolan served as Archbishop of New York — a role that put him at the center of American Catholic life. Appointed by Pope Benedict XVI in 2009, Dolan became one of the most visible prelates in the U.S., known for his media presence, strong conservative voice, and engagement in public issues. Catholic Standard
He turned 75 earlier this year. In the Catholic Church, canon law requires bishops and archbishops to submit their resignation at that age; it’s then up to the pope whether and when to accept it. Dolan submitted his letter of resignation back in February 2025 upon reaching that milestone. The Economic Times
Behind that procedural note is a reality: Dolan’s leadership often intersected with American politics and culture wars, particularly during moments like presidential inaugurations and debates over immigration and life issues. He was a familiar voice on television and in national discussions, and for many Catholics — especially conservatives — he was a reassuring presence. Reuters
But in a Church increasingly focused on pastoral outreach and healing, some insiders saw his departure as part of a broader shift in priorities.
Why Did Cardinal Dolan Resign?
Here’s the thing: Dolan’s resignation isn’t a scandal or forced ouster. It’s largely procedural. Bishops are expected to offer their resignation at age 75 — that’s been the rule since 1983 — and Dolan did just that earlier this year. The Economic Times
What’s notable is the timing of its acceptance and the choice of successor. In some cases, popes let archbishops serve well past age 75. In others, they move quickly to install new leadership. Pope Leo XIV chose to accept Dolan’s resignation on December 18, 2025, and named Bishop Ronald Hicks as the next Archbishop of New York. USCCB
So the story isn’t about why Dolan stepped down — it’s about what comes next.
Meet Bishop Ronald Hicks
The New Archbishop of New York
If you’re wondering where is Cardinal Dolan going next — he’ll stay on as Archbishop Emeritus and help with a smooth leadership transition, but he’s no longer the governing archbishop. Archdiocese of New York
Taking his place is Bishop Ronald Aldon Hicks, a 58-year-old prelate with deep pastoral experience and a very different background from his predecessor. Wikipedia
Hicks was born in Harvey, Illinois, and grew up in South Holland, not far from Chicago — where Pope Leo XIV also hails from. They even went to nearby parks and ate the same local pizza as kids. Yahoo
His journey through the Church has taken him from parish assignments and seminary leadership in Chicago to missionary work in El Salvador and then to serving as Bishop of Joliet since 2020. Along the way, he’s earned respect for his commitment to formation, pastoral care, and lay engagement. CatholicVote org
According to Catholic sources, Hicks brings a calm, humble style rooted in listening and outreach — qualities that many say align closely with Pope Leo’s vision for the Church. Facebook
He’s set to be officially installed in New York on February 6, 2026, stepping into leadership of a diocese with roughly 2.5 million Catholics. Wikipedia
What Does Bishop Hicks’ Appointment Signal?
The change in leadership isn’t just about aging and retirement. It points to a shift in how the Church might engage with society — and how it organizes its own priorities.
Here’s the thing: Dolan and Hicks represent different leadership styles.
-
Dolan was known for his visibility, strong opinions, and willingness to engage in public debate.
-
Hicks is seen as a pastoral shepherd first — someone who listens before speaking and emphasizes unity over confrontation. Reuters
Observers note that Pope Leo himself seems to favor this shift. As the first American pope, he’s already signaled that he wants a clergy that reflects his pastoral instincts — focusing on healing, inclusion, and bridging divides rather than polarizing them. The Washington Post
That doesn’t mean Hicks will abandon all stands on moral teaching — he’s still firmly rooted in Catholic doctrine — but his style is expected to differ from Dolan’s more media-driven presence. AP News
Context Matters: The Challenges Facing the Archdiocese
Another factor in this leadership change is the context in New York itself. The Archdiocese has been dealing with ongoing clergy abuse settlement efforts, which require raising substantial funds — reportedly around $300 million — for compensation to survivors. The Economic Times
There have been difficult decisions, including budget cuts and real estate sales, aimed at meeting those obligations. A new archbishop comes into this situation with heavy responsibilities not just for spiritual guidance but also for navigating institutional challenges. AP News
Hicks has expressed commitment to transparency and healing around these issues, which fits into the broader mission laid out by Pope Leo and his predecessors of pastoral care alongside accountability. AP News
Is Cardinal Dolan Retiring? Where Is He Going Next?
So, is Cardinal Dolan retiring in the everyday sense of the word? Yes and no.
He’s retiring from the daily governance of the Archdiocese of New York — a position he’s held for over a decade and a half. But he’s still a cardinal and will continue to serve the Church in various capacities. Catholic Standard
Many cardinals continue to work in different roles after stepping down from diocesan leadership — teaching, advising, or representing the Church at international events. Dolan’s retirement doesn’t mark the end of his voice in Catholic circles, just a shift in his duties.
Bottom Line: A New Chapter Begins
The appointment of Bishop Ronald Hicks to succeed Cardinal Timothy Dolan is a meaningful moment for American Catholicism. It’s not just a change of names; it reflects a subtle pivot in leadership priorities — toward a Brazil-style, pastoral heart combined with steady governance. The Washington Post
For the Archdiocese of New York, this change comes at a pivotal time — with institutional challenges and evolving social conversations. Hicks brings a fresh, compassionate style that many hope will help guide the Church through both its internal hurdles and its mission in the world.
And while Dolan’s departure may feel like the end of an era to some, the transition invites a deeper look at what it means to shepherd a diverse and dynamic Catholic community in the years ahead.
References
-
Reuters report on Pope Leo replacing Cardinal Dolan with Bishop Hicks. Reuters
-
AP News on Bishop Ronald Hicks named new Archbishop of New York. AP News
-
USCCB announcement of Dolan’s resignation and Hicks’ appointment. USCCB
-
Archdiocese press release outlining the transition and installation details. Archdiocese of New York
-
Catholic Vote overview of Dolan’s stepping down. CatholicVote org
-
ABC7NY coverage of the appointment and Dolan’s comments. ABC7 New York
-
Coverage of financial and abuse settlement context in the New York Archdiocese. AP News
0 Comments